Exploring Seasonality in Wall Street, Europe, and Asia-Pacific Stock Markets

Exploring Seasonality in Wall Street, Europe, and Asia-Pacific Stock Markets

Have you ever wondered whether or not certain months of the year are consistently better or worse for stock markets? If such a relationship does exist, then we would describe it as seasonal. Seasonality is something you often see in all kinds of data. For example, you can probably guess which months of the year ice cream sales consistently spike or when people repeatedly purchase more winter clothing.

Businesses use seasonality every year to plan their ventures, but can investors do the same with stock markets? If we assume that markets are efficient, reflecting all available information at a given time, then changes in stock prices every day (or in this case every month) should behave as white noise. In other words, we should not be able to predict the future based on past performance because markets are random.

I will put this simplified theory to the test for global stock markets. We will analyze the Dow Jones, S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite on Wall Street. Then, we will do the same for the DAX 40, FTSE 100 and CAC 40 to gauge European indices. Finally, I will wrap up with a few major benchmark indices from the Asia-Pacific region: the Nikkei 225, ASX 200 and Hang Seng Index.

Each heatmap chart below contains identical parameters:

  1. Average monthly percent change (+2.5 means the index rose 2.5% on average in that month)
  2. Which months are significant (based on a 95% confidence interval from a regression model)
  3. The average goodness of fit between the 3 regression models (1 for each stock index)

These parameters will be discussed in further detail below.

Dow Jones, S&P 500, Nasdaq Composite Monthly Seasonality

Starting with Wall Street, I have used data on the Dow Jones and S&P 500 since 1950. For the Nasdaq Composite, information since 1973 was used. The most recent month pulled was from December 2022, which applies to all European and Asia-Pacific indices as well. Are there any seasonal effects? Yes!

Historically, it seems that April has been the best month for Wall Street. On average the Dow, S&P and Nasdaq rallied +1.67% in this month. These are also statistically significant. In other words, there is about a 2.6% chance that this +1.67% effect on Wall Street is due to chance within the context of this study.

Meanwhile, September is the only month where all 3 indices have averaged negative and are statistically significant. In this month, the indices averaged -0.8%. I have also highlighted which other months are statistically significant with a “*”. Note that January seems to be a very strong month for the Nasdaq, but it is not significant because, over the years, this month has become progressively weaker.

Finally, and arguably more importantly, notice that the average goodness of fit between the 3 models is 3% (out of a maximum of 100%). What does that mean? On average, about 3% of the variation on Wall Street since the 1950s (‘70s for the Nasdaq) can be explained by seasonality alone (without factoring in any other variables like monetary policy or the unemployment rate).

In other words, while we found meaningful seasonality in April and September, seasonality by itself did a very poor job of explaining how stock markets traded in these months.

Dow Jones, S&P 500, Nasdaq Composite Monthly Seasonality

DAX 40, FTSE 100, CAC 40 Monthly Seasonality

Now let us switch to European indices. It should be noted that the data is not as comprehensive as Wall Street, only going back to 1988. This means that compared to the Dow Jones and S&P 500, we have almost half the number of observations for the DAX 40 (German), FTSE 100 (United Kingdom) and CAC 40 (France).

Still, April has consistently been the best month, similarly to Wall Street. In this month, these European indices averaged 2.43%. For all 3 of them, this month is statistically significant.

Meanwhile, June, August and September have consistently been some of the worst months, averaging -0.67%, -1.23% and -1.57%, respectively. These are all statistically significant. As such, it seems you can find more weak months for this corner of global stock exchanges.

Similarly, with Wall Street, the average goodness of fit for seasonality in European indices is quite low at 6%. Once again this means that while we can identify meaningful seasonality, by itself it is not a good indicator of how these markets have performed in April, June, August and September over the years.

DAX 40, FTSE 100, CAC 40 Monthly Seasonality

Nikkei 225, ASX 200, Hang Seng Index Monthly Seasonality

Wrapping up with Asia-Pacific markets, we will be analyzing the Nikkei 225 (Japan) and Hang Seng Index (Hong Kong) since 1971, along with the ASX 200 (Australia) since 1992.

Much like with Wall Street and European indices, April appears to have consistently and significantly been the best month for these APAC stock markets. The Nikkei 225, Hang Seng Index and ASX 200 averaged about 2% over the years.

Meanwhile, August and September have consistently and significantly been the worst periods. During these months, the indices returned -0.7% and -1% on average, respectively.

Like with other markets, the average goodness of fit was approximately 4%. Once again, while we can identify meaningful seasonality, by itself it did not do a good job of explaining how these markets performed in April, August and September over the years.

Nikkei 225, ASX 200, Hang Seng Index Monthly Seasonality

Should We Care About Seasonality in Stock Markets?

The takeaways from this deep dive can be split up into 4 key findings:

  1. Statistically significant seasonality is present in global stock markets
  2. April has consistently been the best month between the US, Europe and Asia
  3. September is the only month between all areas that has consistently disappointed
  4. Seasonality by itself has been a poor predictor of performance

For those with a keen eye, you might have noticed that October, November and December have historically been strong months for these global markets. But, as tested with the regression model, for the most part, these months have not been statistically significant.

With that in mind, while we can identify reoccurring patterns in global stock markets, which to a certain extent pours cold water on the “white noise” hypothesis, it probably will not hurt much to brush aside these effects in analyzing stock markets generally.

Australian Dollar Spikes After RBA Hikes. Will AUD/USD Find Higher Ground?

Australian Dollar Spikes After RBA Hikes. Will AUD/USD Find Higher Ground?

The Australian Dollar roared over 67 cents after the RBA tightened monetary policy following a pause last month. The 25 basis point lift took the cash rate to 3.85%.

In the accompanying statement on monetary policy, the bank said, “Some further tightening of monetary policy may be required to ensure that inflation returns to target in a reasonable timeframe, but that will depend upon how the economy and inflation evolve.”

They highlighted the tight labour market and that wages had started to pick up.

Australian retail sales and trade data will be released this week followed by building approvals figures next week. The Citibank Economic Surprise Index (ESI) in the chart below is leaning toward a possible beat for AUD fundamental data coming up.

image1.png

Data: Bloomberg

Prior to the meeting, interest rate markets were pricing in a fifty-fifty chance of a 25 basis point hike later this year. Now that it has arrived, the market is recalibrating and digesting the intonation of the statement. The reaction in AUD/USD has been more abrupt.

It would seem that last week’s inflation figures stoked some flames of concern with headline CPI of 7.0% slightly beating forecasts of 6.9% year-on-year to the end of March and it was against 7.8% previously.

The RBA’s preferred measure of trimmed-mean CPI was 6.6% year-on-year for the same period instead of estimates of 6.7% and 6.9% previously.

The headline CPI figure has been above the RBA’s mandated 2 – 3% inflation target since the second quarter of 2021 while the trimmed mean has been above the target since the first quarter of 2022.

The RBA didn’t start raising the cash rate until May 2022. The shortcomings of the trimmed mean measure may have been exposed by this episode.

This adjusted inflation gauge looks at the middle of 70% of the headline CPI basket. That is, it eliminates the 15% of the basket that rose the most and least.

This symmetric approach means that if one side of the basket is seeing far more aggressive price changes, the other side of the basket being eliminated doesn’t necessarily evenly compensate for it.

When inflation pressures are moving significantly up or down, the value of appraising the underlying price changes using a core method such as the trimmed mean might not be as useful as it has been historically.

What is apparent from today’s decision is that the RBA are back in inflation-fighting mode.

The Federal Reserve and European Central Bank (ECB) will meet later this week while the Bank of England will gather next week. Interest rate markets have priced in a 25 basis point lift by all three central banks.

The RBA’s full monetary policy statement can be read here.

AUD/USD 1 MINUTE CHART PRICE REACTION TO RBA HIKE

Live prices can be found here.

image2.png

 

Hoping For an Early Fed Pivot Does Not Mean We Will Get One

Hoping For an Early Fed Pivot Does Not Mean We Will Get One

Every economic age has its dominant phrase. Think of the ‘irrational exuberance’ which then-Federal Reserve Chair Alan Greenspan fretted about during the 1990’s dot-com bubble. If that’s too far back for you, what about European Central Bank chief Mario Draghi in 2012 promising skeptical markets that he’d do ‘whatever it takes’ to save the Euro?

The buzzword of this inflation-ravaged era is more succinct. In fact, it’s just one word – ‘pivot.’

For our purposes it means the point at which the United States Federal Reserve will feel it can stop raising interest rates and begin to offer the possibility that they could start to go down.

It’s easy to see why that word dominates. 2022 brought, among other dark things, interest rate rises unprecedented in the working lives of many people now engaged with financial markets. The US central bank has hit the monetary brakes no fewer than seven times, pushing the benchmark rate up to a target range of 4.25-4.5%. That’s the highest rate in fifteen years. Moreover, while there are clear rhetorical signs that the Fed is now more cautious about raising rates than it was back in the summer, there are equally clear signals that borrowing costs will go higher yet and that it may not top out below 5%.

Given that the Fed Funds rate spent much of the time between 2009 and 2021 barely above zero, the scale of the turnaround has been astonishing.

And given that so many market participants cut their teeth in a long era of docile inflation, cheap money and ever-flowing credit, it’s no wonder that so many should be keen that the Fed does indeed pivot as soon as possible. The thing about Golden Ages is that people always want them back.

But that doesn’t mean they come back. Of course, the key to whether or not the Fed will, in fact, pivot, will be found in the inflation data. And the picture there is still very unclear.

Boosted by a number of factors, from the war in Ukraine through to Covid’s supply-chain havoc and a general rethink of the previously dominant trend toward ever-more globalization, prices surged in 2022 by measures not seen for fully 40 years. The US was not alone in facing this gale, of course. Other countries did so too, and some had it a lot worse. Inflation has run hotter in Europe thanks among other factors to its energy dependence on Russia.

Even Japan has seen a resurgence of pricing power, where inflation has been thought dead for decades.

But the US still runs the table, and it’s the success of the US response which will matter most. And there are some encouraging signs. The Fed’s preferred measure of inflation continued to slacken in November, providing another indicator that price pressures may indeed have peaked earlier in the year.

The Personal Consumption Expenditures price index, or PCE, rose 5.5% on the year, well below the 6.1% rise seen just a month earlier. The core measure, which cuts out the volatile effects of food and energy costs, was up by a more reassuring 4.7% annualized. Both readings were at their lowest since October 2021.

The release chimes with official Consumer Price Index data for the same month, which showed a similar slackening.

Nevertheless, price rises there still stand at 7.1%, which is a very long way indeed from the 2% rate targeted by the Fed. Moreover, the US central bank’s mandate is to promote stable prices and maximum employment. There may not be many active in the markets today who remember the inflationary pressures of the 1970s and early 1980s. However, there will be many in the Fed who do remember them, and how hard-won the victory was. The monetarist students at the US central bank will be only too aware that they can’t afford to end the rate rising process until inflation – and as importantly, inflation expectations – have been actually and obviously seen to be crushed.

Hence, we see things like stocks falling despite robust Gross Domestic Product numbers. Investors are seeing everything through the inflation prism, and any sign that the Fed’s action has yet to clearly cool economic activity just has investors ever-more convinced that the pivot is not here yet.

5.5% inflation may be better than 6.1%, but it’s still outrunning the Fed’s target by a huge amount, and there’s simply no way policymakers are going to stop fighting while that’s the case. Chair Jerome Powell and the rest of the Open Market Committee well know that their success in getting inflation down will define their time.

Many commentators think we might get very close to pivot territory by the late spring of next year, but in truth we’d probably have to see a marked moderation in wage momentum and, probably, employment growth. Both have remained surprisingly strong despite the Fed’s actions.

Inflation also has a nasty tendency to get sticky. Faced with rising prices, employees demand higher wages, which only add to cost pressures at a time when there’s usually little option but to pass these on again to consumers. And so on…

The upshot of all this is that it could yet be a very long time before the Fed actually does ‘pivot,’ and any prognosis that such a thing could happen in the early part of 2023 depends on evidence of a pretty rapid economic slowdown coming soon. If the economic data don’t start to support this thesis unambiguously in the early months of the year, then the waiting for the pivot could prove a much longer game than many in the markets now hope it’ll be.

Forecast for Quotes: Take part in the new Demo Account Contest.

Forecast for Quotes: Take part in the new Demo Account Contest.

Dear clients,

LiteFinance presents a new service — Contracts for Quote Forecasts — in a demo mode.

You can place contracts for rate changes in any trading asset the LiteFinance company provides. This service allows you to profit from correct forecasts for quotes.The new section is working in a demo mode.

We invite our clients to be the first to test the new service and earn real money by participating in the Forecast for Quotes demo account contest. The most successful participants will share the prize fund of $62,000 in real money.

LiteFinance will give away $1,000 every 12 hours during a month. Five traders with the biggest contest account equity at the end of each stage will be awarded the following prizes:

  • 1st place — $500;
  • 2nd place — $200;
  • 3d place — $100;
  • 4th place — $100;
  • 5th place — $100.

How to participate in the Forecast for Quotes contest?

  1. Log in to your Client Profile and fully verify your email, phone number, name, and address
  2. Switch your Profile to a demo mode in the top-right corner of the Profile page.
  3. Click on the Quotes Forecasts tab in the side menu of your Client Profile, and then the “Contest” tab.
  4. Click on “Participate”, and a contest demo account with a $10,000 start deposit will be automatically opened for you.

How to make contracts for forecasts?

  1. Choose an asset you want to make a forecast for.
  2. Enter a contract size and a projected rate change in points.
  3. Indicate the direction of your quote forecast: “Higher” or “‎Lower”.

If your prediction is correct, the contract will close at a profit; if the price reaches the predetermined level in the opposite direction, your contract will close at a loss.

Try your luck and mastery, and leave your rivals far behind!

We thank you for your assistance and hope you will appreciate this new earning opportunity!

Faithfully yours,

LiteFinance.