US President Donald Trump’s renewed threats to strike Iran, combined with Iranian negotiators once again walking away from talks in Switzerland, have revived uncertainty surrounding the future of one of the world’s most critical oil transit routes.
Although negotiations continue to make progress, uncertainty over global oil supply security remains elevated due to the risk environment surrounding the Strait of Hormuz—an issue that many market participants appear to be overlooking.
Some social media users have even begun referring to Hormuz as “Schrödinger’s Strait,” and for good reason. The issue is no longer simply whether ships can pass through unhindered by Iranian forces or a potential US blockade. It is also about whether shipping companies, insurers, banks, and other participants in the oil trade can reliably track cargo movements and verify the safety of shipping routes.
Energy analytics firm Kpler recently argued that the risks stemming from the conflict involving the United States, Israel, and Iran go well beyond the question of whether the strait is technically open or closed. The ability to monitor tanker traffic has become a critical component in assessing overall risk.
Most media coverage and market analysis surrounding the Strait of Hormuz focuses on a simplified narrative built around two outcomes: open or closed. However, Kpler trade-risk analyst Ana Subasic warned last week that this framework is misleading because many other factors influence the situation.
She noted that oil cargoes require reliable tracking throughout their journey for both insurance and sanctions-compliance purposes.
“A vessel may be able to transit the strait,” Subasic said, “but if its movements cannot be reliably monitored due to degraded or manipulated positioning data, the voyage record becomes questionable. Port-entry verification fails, risk mapping breaks down, and reconstructing the vessel’s route becomes subject to dispute.”
Such information is essential for all parties involved in oil shipments. Yet the market has largely ignored these concerns while focusing on the simplistic “open versus closed” narrative that directly influences oil futures prices.
In the physical oil market, however, these details often matter far more than whether the strait is technically open. This reality has frequently been reflected in significant divergences between futures prices and physical crude delivery prices.
The situation may become even more complicated in the months ahead.
Lloyd’s List reported last week that Iran has introduced a mandatory insurance system for all vessels passing through the Strait of Hormuz, to be administered by a newly established Persian Gulf Strait Authority.
According to the report, insurance coverage will initially be provided free of charge, though that arrangement is not expected to last indefinitely.
The publication cited an Iranian document stating:
“Insurance will initially be provided free of charge to vessel owners, with all costs covered by the Islamic Republic of Iran. The Persian Gulf Strait Authority reserves the right to impose insurance fees in the future, at which point vessel owners will be required to purchase and renew the necessary coverage.”
The new authority will also be the sole body authorized to issue transit permits and determine the routes vessels must follow while navigating the strait.
Lloyd’s List quoted one tanker owner as saying: “This is madness. The whole situation has become chaotic.”
The development illustrates just how complex the reality has become and why focusing solely on whether the strait is open or closed fails to capture the full picture.
As Subasic explained, the more important questions are: “Who is transiting the strait? When are they transiting? Under what level of risk? And does that risk create exposure for voyage stakeholders such as shipowners, charterers, insurers, banks, and cargo receivers?”
Before the initial US and Israeli strikes on Iran, this information was generally available to all market participants. Today, significant gaps have emerged in the data.
Insurers and banks are particularly uncomfortable with such information gaps, especially amid an active military conflict, a complex sanctions regime, and heightened maritime security risks.
The result is higher insurance costs, as uncertainty and limited visibility increase the expense of transporting oil cargoes.
Malaysia’s New Straits Times recently reported that insurance costs for a very large crude carrier (VLCC) sailing from the Persian Gulf previously ranged between $150,000 and $225,000 per voyage before the conflict.
Following the outbreak of hostilities, those costs surged to between $5 million and $7.5 million per voyage.
Yet these dramatic cost increases may not represent the biggest long-term challenge. The more significant issue lies in the persistent information gaps highlighted by Subasic.
Those gaps are likely to keep uncertainty surrounding oil transportation through the Strait of Hormuz elevated for some time, regardless of how much progress peace negotiations make or what outcomes emerge in the coming weeks.
The fact that these additional risks have not been fully reflected in oil futures markets also provides further evidence of the growing disconnect between the physical oil market and the paper-trading market.