After more than three months of fighting and intermittent negotiations, Washington and Tehran now appear, according to reports, to be on the verge of reaching an agreement that would bring their conflict to an end. However, according to sources in Washington, Tehran, and London who spoke exclusively to OilPrice over the past few days, the political and military drama of recent weeks may ultimately end as a loud story with limited practical consequences.
A Washington-based source working closely with legal operations at the US Treasury Department told the website over the weekend: “There is a very strong chance that the United States will end up with an agreement that looks remarkably similar to the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), commonly known as the Iran nuclear deal, although we may lose a little while Iran gains a little.”
But what are the prospects for the expected peace agreement? And what could happen to energy prices afterward?
US war objectives
From the American perspective, President Donald Trump identified four primary objectives from the outset of the war against Iran and its proxies in February, all of which received full backing from members of his administration at the time.
The first objective was to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear arsenal.
The second was to destroy or weaken Iran’s missile stockpiles and production capabilities.
The third was regime change.
The fourth was to end Tehran’s financing and arming of its regional proxies.
So how much progress has been made toward these goals?
Iran’s nuclear program
Regarding the nuclear program—the most important objective for Washington—the US Department of Defense announced that the Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant had been rendered “inoperable.”
The above-ground enrichment facility at Natanz was also said to have been “completely destroyed,” while the underground laboratories suffered what were described as “extensive” damages.
The same applies to the Isfahan Nuclear Technology Center, which serves as a key hub for converting uranium into the gas required for enrichment activities.
However, up to 440 kilograms of uranium enriched to 60%, which the International Atomic Energy Agency lost track of last year, remains unaccounted for.
The agency also acknowledges that it does not know the full scope of Iran’s current activities, particularly at undisclosed sites.
Missiles and military capabilities
As for the second objective, US intelligence assessments indicate that roughly 70% of Iran’s pre-war ballistic missile stockpile remains intact.
At the same time, around 70% of its missile launchers have reportedly been destroyed.
Strikes targeting Iran’s Defense Ministry and military logistics facilities also destroyed 15 major weapons production sites linked to the development of advanced ballistic missiles.
Iran’s manufacturing capabilities were further eroded following US and Israeli attacks on three major steel plants in Mobarakeh, Khuzestan, and Sefid Dasht.
Nevertheless, US intelligence officials warned earlier this month that Iran’s defense industrial base is recovering faster than expected, aided by components supplied through covert networks originating in China.
Regime change
As for the third objective—regime change—Trump could argue that it was partially achieved through the elimination of former Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei and dozens of senior religious, political, and military figures in strikes carried out in coordination with Israel.
Despite that, Iran’s hardline Islamic system remains intact and continues to enjoy strong support from the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, the ideological guardian of the 1979 revolution.
Dismantling the proxy network
The fourth objective has arguably seen the clearest success so far.
Operation “Epic Wrath” reportedly dismantled the command structure linking Tehran to its network of armed groups across the region.
The deaths of several key leaders transformed those groups into more independent regional actors rather than a coordinated and unified front.
According to US Central Command, Iran’s ability to use its proxies as a tool of regional power has suffered a major blow.
Trump and political considerations
“There are enough achievements here for the president to claim some form of victory to his supporters, allowing him to strike a deal that has become increasingly important with the approach of the November midterm elections,” the US source said.
Although Trump is legally barred from seeking another presidential term, he may still seek to preserve his family’s political influence in the future, which would require continued support from the Republican Party.
For that reason, he is closely watching the party’s electoral prospects and understands the direct relationship between energy prices, the US economy, and election outcomes.
Oil and elections
With gasoline prices remaining above $4 per gallon in the United States, historical data suggests that every $10-per-barrel move in crude oil prices typically translates into a change of roughly 25 to 30 cents per gallon at the pump.
Furthermore, every one-cent increase in average gasoline prices reduces annual consumer spending by more than $1 billion, weighing on economic growth.
The political significance is considerable. Since 1896, incumbent US presidents have won re-election 11 out of 11 times when the economy was not in recession during the two years preceding the election.
By contrast, incumbents facing elections during a recession succeeded only once in seven attempts.
A similar pattern applies to midterm elections.
Iran’s position
The challenge for the US negotiating team is that Tehran believes it cannot defeat the United States in this war, but it also does not believe it will be defeated.
Iran’s leadership and population have grown accustomed to the economic and political hardships resulting from more than four decades of international sanctions. As a result, continued pressure is not viewed as a decisive factor.
At the same time, the possibility of reaching an agreement that improves daily life for Iranians makes patience an acceptable strategy.
“We must remember that this time Iran holds a genuine bargaining chip through its continued control of the Strait of Hormuz, which is why it is seeking a better deal than the nuclear agreement reached during the Obama administration,” the US source added.
Bigger demands than the 2015 deal
A senior source working closely with Iran’s Oil Ministry said Tehran’s demands from Washington will be significantly greater than they were in 2015.
“We are now talking about tens of billions of dollars in compensation for war-related damages, although in the United States it will likely be presented under a different label, perhaps as an investment fund,” he said.
“In return, Iran will take its time implementing its commitments because the Revolutionary Guard believes that any peace agreement with Trump could simply be a way to maintain calm until the midterm elections and then resume the conflict afterward.”
What happens to oil prices?
If a peace agreement is signed and appears sustainable, a period of two to four weeks should be sufficient to begin clearing the bottlenecks that have built up in the Gulf and restoring normal shipping patterns.
A further two to four weeks may then be required for flows to return fully to normal levels, according to Vikas Dwivedi, Global Energy Strategist at Macquarie Group.
Under this base-case scenario, where markets become convinced that the agreement is genuine and sustainable, he expects a sharp and immediate selloff in oil.
“We expect a decline of around $20 per barrel within just one week,” Dwivedi said.
He added that this would likely be followed by two weeks of relative stabilization, before the market begins repricing logistical and financial factors.
“After that, we expect the market to find itself facing a significant supply surplus once again, as alternative sources remain available and oil flows through the Strait of Hormuz resume, potentially leading to an overshoot to the downside.”
He concluded: “Ultimately, we expect prices to return to levels more consistent with supply and demand fundamentals, settling within what we view as a fair-value range of $65 to $70 per barrel.”