There is an old military saying that “no plan survives first contact with the enemy,” and it appears that Iran may have ignored this rule in its response to the recent attacks by the United States and Israel. These attacks, along with similar strikes carried out last year, can be viewed as an extension of the war that Iran effectively launched through Hamas’ deadly attacks on Israel on October 7, 2023. In any case, several unexpected factors are now emerging that could threaten to prolong disruptions in the Middle East for years to come, with oil, gas, and gasoline prices rising significantly.
Iran’s new leader, who closely resembles his predecessor, has encouraged this situation by maintaining the effective blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, through which roughly one-third of global oil supplies and about one-fifth of liquefied natural gas shipments pass. At the same time, Iran has said the world should be prepared for oil prices reaching $200 per barrel while its forces target commercial shipping. But is that outcome likely?
Difficulty dealing with the Strait of Hormuz
Solving the main problem — the effective closure of the Strait of Hormuz — appears nearly impossible at this stage of the conflict, given the operational constraints under which US President Donald Trump wants American forces to operate.
A senior source in Washington working closely with the US Treasury Department said that Trump does not want to deploy troops on the ground around the strait, which is the only realistic option for guaranteeing safe passage for ships. The source added that sending naval vessels to escort commercial ships would still leave them vulnerable to drone attacks and missile strikes from Iran, as well as fast boats from the Revolutionary Guard. Even before that, the US Navy would have to clear naval mines in the area.
The official said the Trump administration is working on a plan to secure the strait that includes providing insurance for ships through the US International Development Finance Corporation, but no final proposals or specific timeline have yet emerged.
Increasing supplies from other sources
In the absence of reopening this vital route for global oil supplies, efforts will shift toward increasing supplies from other sources. Several solutions have already begun to be implemented, similar to the measures taken after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, when Brent crude rose to more than $120 per barrel, a level it approached again following the recent attacks on Iran.
One effective strategy at that time was releasing strategic oil reserves from member countries of the International Energy Agency (IEA). Last week, the agency recommended releasing 400 million barrels, far exceeding the previous five largest releases combined, the largest of which was 180 million barrels split into two tranches in 2022.
US Energy Secretary Chris Wright said Trump has authorized the release of 172 million barrels from the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve starting next week. However, some member countries cannot release their reserves immediately, and it could take up to 120 days for the full additional volume to reach the market.
Sanction waivers for oil consumption
Another mechanism to increase global supply involves granting temporary exemptions allowing some countries to use energy from sanctioned producers. In 2022, this approach was applied to oil from sanctioned Venezuela, and enforcement was also relaxed for Iranian oil. Now, after the removal of Nicolás Maduro from Venezuela’s presidency in January, Venezuelan oil can be used more freely by the United States, although volumes remain limited after years of decline in the country’s oil sector.
At present, Russia is likely to be the main beneficiary, as the US Treasury Department issued a temporary 30-day exemption, expiring on April 11, 2026, allowing some countries, including India, to purchase sanctioned Russian oil. Russia has also indicated it is ready to resume exports of natural gas and liquefied natural gas to countries affected by the Iranian conflict, including those that depend on Qatari gas. Nevertheless, this increase will not fully offset the ongoing losses caused by the halt of oil shipments through the Strait of Hormuz.
Potential impact on prices
Given the ongoing volatility of the conflict, it is impossible to determine the exact scale of lost oil supply on a consistent basis. However, the World Bank has previously estimated the price impact of supply disruptions. According to its estimates:
A small disruption: supply losses of 500,000 to 2 million barrels per day, similar to the 2011 Libyan civil war, could raise prices by 3–13%, bringing Brent to around $75–$82 per barrel after it had stood at $73 before the latest attacks.
A medium disruption: supply losses of 3 to 5 million barrels per day, comparable to the 2003 Iraq war, could push prices up by 21–35%, to around $88–$98 per barrel.
A major disruption: supply losses of 6 to 8 million barrels per day, similar to the 1973 oil crisis, could drive prices up by 56–75%, to roughly $113–$127 per barrel.
The World Bank did not factor in the effective closure of the Strait of Hormuz, but Vikas Dwivedi, chief energy strategist at Macquarie Group, believes such a scenario could trigger a chain of events that might push prices to $150 per barrel or more.
The political dimension in the United States
For Trump, the key issue is how these figures affect the US economy and the prospects of both himself and the Republican Party in the midterm elections on November 3, as well as in the upcoming presidential race. Historical data indicate that every $10 increase in the price of a barrel of oil typically leads to a rise of about 25–30 cents in the price of a gallon of gasoline, resulting in more than $1 billion in lost annual consumer spending for each one-cent increase in gasoline prices.
Trump is known to be determined to avoid dragging the United States into a prolonged conflict that cannot be won, as happened with Russia in Ukraine. He has previously pledged to end “endless wars,” a stance that has resonated with his political base. A short conflict could be justified as serving US national security interests, but he understands that any prolonged confrontation would likely erode support among the voters on whom he relies.
A senior source in the European Union said that Trump initially set four clear objectives for the attacks on Iran, and that within the next two to three weeks he is expected to declare that they have broadly been achieved, while continuing to monitor Iran’s nuclear program, missile capabilities, and regional militias. The source added that the United States would intervene again only if it sees a direct threat, and would otherwise withdraw.
Overall, the prospect of oil reaching $200 per barrel, as suggested by Iran, still appears unlikely. International measures and alternative supply sources could help limit excessive price increases, despite continued tensions surrounding the Strait of Hormuz.